Insights and Analyses

• Institutional and systemic barriers contribute to disparities in educational attainment for immigrants, which also varies by immigration status. As of 2021, across the state, 18% of naturalized citizens and 7% of U.S.-born individuals had less than a high school degree, compared to 28% of lawful residents and 53% of undocumented immigrants.

• Disparities in educational attainment also vary by race, as different immigrant communities face unique sets of institutional and systemic challenges like language access. Data disaggregation is critical in pointing out these disparities. Among Asian American immigrants in California, in 2021, 82% of Indian immigrants had a bachelor’s degree or higher while only 23% of Hmong, 21% of Cambodian, and 20% of Laotians did. Among Pacific Islander immigrants, only about 17% of Fijian and 10% of Tongan immigrants had a bachelor’s degree or higher.

• Some immigrants arrive in the U.S. with credentials and certifications from their country of origin. However, due to barriers in licensing and credentialing, many immigrants are unable to exercise their skills and expertise, leaving many underemployed or unemployed.

• Immigrant and refugee healthcare professionals represented a critical pool of responders during the COVID-19 pandemic. In 2021, immigrants and refugees accounted for more than 18 percent of healthcare workers in the U.S. and 35 percent of healthcare workers in California. However, the Migration Policy Institute (MPI) estimated that in 2021, about 270,000 immigrant healthcare professionals were either unemployed or working in lower-skilled jobs. California had the highest number (60,000 individuals) of immigrant health care workers experiencing skill underutilization, according to 2017 estimates by MPI.

• In 2021, over 408,000 undocumented students were enrolled in U.S. colleges and universities, comprising 1.9 percent of all college students nationwide. Within that number, 83,000 undocumented college students are in California, the highest of any state.

• In 2022, UCLA students launched the Opportunity for All campaign with the goal of opening employment opportunities to all UC students, regardless of immigration status. It is estimated that about 44,326 undocumented students in higher education throughout the state are barred from employment opportunities. In 2023, the UC Board of Regents initially voted to develop an implementation plan to hire undocumented students; however, in January 2024 it suspended that plan. Yet, the Opportunity for All Act (AB 2586) has garnered support at the state level. While already approved by the California Assembly Higher Education Committee, if passed, it would open employment opportunities for undocumented students in the UC, CSU, and community college systems.

Business leaders and educators in Orange County formed a long-term partnership to create a training program that prepares youth for jobs in the county’s growth industries.

In 2006, the Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce partnered with the Santa Ana Unified School District to develop a training curriculum that provides students, many of whom were a part of the growing immigrant population in the city, with job training in the six growth sectors of the Santa Ana region. This unique partnership is narrowing the skills gap between the local workforce and local industries, providing college as well as career preparedness programs, and acclimating to shifting labor markets. Now a nonprofit organization, High School Inc. (HSI) Academies Foundation, is training local students in automotive, transportation and logistics; culinary arts and hospitality; engineering; global business; healthcare; and new media sectors. The 2022-2023 HSI program supported 1,453 students, resulting in a 95% graduation rate among students in the 12th grade, 871 students that received industry certifications, 770 students that participated in project-based activities, and 169 students that completed internships. Further, 88% of High School Inc. Students enrolled in higher education. To learn more about the program read here.

Photo credit: High School Inc. Academies Foundation

Resources

• Articles:

  • Who’s Missing from California’s Community Colleges

  • The Pandemic’s Effects on Higher Education

  • Curbing Enrollment Decline and Investing in California’s Community College Students

  • As U.S. Health Care System Buckles under Pandemic, Immigrant & Refugee Professionals Could Represent a Critical Resource

  • Foreign Doctors Could Help Fight Coronavirus. But U.S. Blocks Many

  • Removing Barriers for Immigrant Medical Professionals is Critical to Help Fight Coronavirus

  • Barriers to Work: Improving Access to Licensed Occupations for Immigrants with Work Authorizations

• Reports:

  • Students Need Financial Support for Higher Education & Career Paths

  • Getting California’s K-12 Students Back to School

  • Advancing Equity for Undocumented Students and Students from Mixed-Status Families at the University of California

  • Leaving Money on the Table: The Persistence of Brain Waste Among College-Educated Immigrants

  • California’s Immigrant and U.S.-Born Parents of Young and Elementary-School-Age-Children

  • Skills for an Inclusive Economic Recovery: A Call for Action, Equity, and Accountability

  • The Roadmap for Racial Equity Special Edition: Immigrants and English Learners

  • Amplifying Impact: Combining Investment in English Language Skills and Digital Learning

• Data:

  • Higher Ed Immigration Portal